In another post, you asked about worldly historical evidence, I posted 3 detailed replies but they have gone unaswered.
No need to make any efforts for me. One cant "prove" something like the 5,000 Year Cycle. It is a statement of blind faith. And, for me, an unsatisfactorily explained one. What would interest me is the history of the concept;
- how, when and by whom was it introduced into the BK consciousness as a mental plug? It appears to be very early on in the Yagya.
Where is the first record of this and what was the explanation made?
The sort of down to earth question I ask would be;
- What and where is the mechanism that 'tick-tock' controls to the exact moment repetitively?
Can you explain, scientifically, the entropic mechanism by which a Universe at its lowest state of energy raises itself once back up to its highest state again?
Half seriously, I would also ask, does that included Leap Years or not? When did they start? Where there Leap years in the Golden Age (No, do not bother answering).
What ... are we talking about 5,000 circles of the Sun or 23 hours, 56 minutes and 4.091 seconds x 365.2564 days x 5,000? Tropical ... anomalistic ... sidereal years? The devil is in the detail.
You see, the the universe does not work to such nice, neat, clean numbers. There is no reason for it to do so and all our clever little regular divisions of time are purely human, relative, approximately and dating only from a couple of thousand years ago ... how did the eternal Universe know them in advance? We also have been given indications that the BKWSU is all set to "review" its interpretation of the 5,000 Year Cycle ... as their predictions appear likely to fail once again.
John asks a question that we have discussed (or raised to silent response) elsewhere. For the Cycle to repeat, all the parts of the Universe will have to return to their original place in the macrocosm and microcosm. Now just a little surface clean up of India via Civil War and sinking of the continents.
How, within the BK model, do we regain all the satellites shooting off out into space?
Think about it. If each Cycle you remove a few thousands tonnes of mass and propel them out into outer space, after a few thousand Cycles, you will have no mass left for there to be a planet earth. Pre-flag on the moon, not something they would have thought about in 1930s Hyderabad.
Its a only mental plug, not a reality and I fear your ideas are closer to devotional poetry than hard science. The problem is, you start from the point of hugely unproven assumptions. There is nothing wrong with devotional poetry, mind you. Only it serves a different interest
- ... to inflame faith rather than reason.